Quick Answer: Buy a treadmill like the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 ($2,499 list, frequently discounted) if you want to run, incline-train, or build real cardio fitness — it packs a 4.25 CHP motor and a -3% to 12% incline range a walking pad can’t touch. Buy a walking pad like the WalkingPad P1 (~$399) if your goal is simply moving more during the day — it folds to about 4 inches thick, slides under a desk or couch, and runs 0.5-3.72 mph for walking while you work. Runners and serious cardio trainers should get the treadmill; anyone trying to add daily steps around a desk job should get the walking pad.
A treadmill and a walking pad both move a belt under your feet, but they’re built for opposite lifestyles. A treadmill is a large, powerful machine designed around running — a real motor, a long cushioned deck, side rails, and often incline, all of which take up a dedicated corner of a room. A walking pad strips all of that away: no incline, no console, no rails, just a slim motorized belt built for walking speeds that folds flat and disappears under furniture. Neither is a smaller version of the other — they solve different problems.
By the numbers: The CDC recommends at least 150 minutes of moderate aerobic activity per week, and a walking pad is built to help you bank that time in short bursts while you work — most top out around 3.7 to 4 mph, a brisk walk, not a jog. A treadmill is built for higher intensity: per Harvard Health Publishing, a 155-pound person burns roughly 600 calories per hour running at 6 mph, a pace no walking pad can safely support. On the hardware side, the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 packs a 4.25 CHP motor with a -3% to 12% incline range, while the WalkingPad P1 has no incline at all and folds to about 4 inches thick for storage.
Treadmill vs walking pad at a glance
| Treadmill | Walking Pad | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Running, incline training, real cardio intensity | Daily steps, under-desk walking |
| Top speed | 10-12 mph | ~3.7-4 mph (up to ~7.5 mph on 2-in-1 models) |
| Incline | Yes, up to 12-15% on most models | None |
| Footprint when stored | Large even folded upright | Folds to ~4 in thick, slides under furniture |
| Entry price | ~$999-$2,499 | ~$180-$849 |
Why a treadmill wins for running and intensity
NordicTrack Commercial 1750
- 4.25 CHP motor with a -3% to 12% decline-to-incline range for real hill and interval work.
- Generous cushioning and a large belt built for an unrestricted running stride.
- 16-inch swiveling touchscreen for iFIT classes and guided incline programming.
Get your running gear delivered fast — try Amazon Prime free for 30 days and have shoes or a heart-rate strap waiting before your first run.
Running and incline work are where a walking pad simply can’t compete — you need a real motor and a deck built for impact at speed. Per Harvard Health Publishing, a 155-pound person burns roughly 600 calories per hour running at 6 mph, a pace that requires a machine like the NordicTrack Commercial 1750’s 4.25 CHP motor to sustain without straining. Budget-conscious runners don’t need to spend flagship money either: see our best treadmill guide for the full rankings, including the Horizon 7.0 AT (~$999) as a true 3.0 CHP option with no subscription required.
Why a walking pad wins for daily steps and space
WalkingPad P1
- Folds in half to about 4 inches thick — slides under a couch, bed, or standing desk.
- Runs 0.5-3.72 mph, purpose-built for walking while you work rather than running.
- Supports users up to 220 lb in a fraction of a treadmill's footprint.
If the goal is simply moving more during a desk-bound day, a walking pad wins outright — the CDC’s 150-minutes-per-week activity target is far easier to hit when the machine lives an arm’s length from your keyboard instead of in a garage. The WalkingPad P1 folds flat enough to disappear against a wall between sessions, and at roughly a third of a treadmill’s price it’s a much lower-commitment first purchase. See our best walking pad guide for the full lineup, including 2-in-1 models with a fold-up handrail for light jogging.
How to decide
- Training for running or real cardio intensity: buy the treadmill. Nothing about a walking pad's motor or deck supports running-speed impact.
- Mostly sitting at a desk and want more daily movement: buy the walking pad. It's built for exactly that, and folds away when you're done.
- Tight on floor space: the walking pad wins easily — it folds to about 4 inches thick versus a treadmill's dedicated footprint even when folded upright.
- Tight on budget: a walking pad starts around $180-$260 for a basic model, well under even a budget treadmill like the Horizon 7.0 AT (~$999).
- Want both eventually: many home gyms run a treadmill for structured workouts and a walking pad under the desk for the rest of the day — they don't compete for the same use case.
The bottom line
Buy the treadmill if running, incline training, or real cardio intensity is the goal — the NordicTrack Commercial 1750 delivers a 4.25 CHP motor and a -3% to 12% incline range that no walking pad can match. Buy the walking pad if the goal is simply moving more during a desk-bound day — the WalkingPad P1 (~$399) folds to about 4 inches thick and makes the CDC’s 150-minutes-per-week target easy to hit without leaving your desk. Still filling out the rest of your setup? Our best home gym equipment guide covers everything else you’ll need, and our treadmill vs elliptical guide compares the treadmill against another popular cardio pick.